deviation management in pharmacovigilance

1: Record-keeping requirement - - 1 Quality management system: 1. Where appropriate immediate action should be taken. relevant comments and compliance to regulatory requirements for feasibility of Determination that the correct solutions, standards, buffers, media, reagents etc. The impacted process due to incident/unplanned deviation shall be restarted only after QA approval of correction. hVMo7+w$VB!m rTi(g8nvIi]V&\k6GS&9Zl 2>uTNkKx4zj[AQzhh.fkf{2?A2L/m5jvbiVcoZ4by(v[]5?^E:qUv.6]~y>ANi^4we]sVLm/qsjq[yRp)Cm^r~b\uUwV5[lqTn~ij|D%}8pvF-\gLR:^!CQQr5a!(b40(:1-=NyTcekQt}cc 5mdFlec:5@kqp~H'S2%Q06J],q"\WKx)f$;@G.PI qi9 'NL \8MBx {/#' >s>9v E9luk'7M51| _vaFQj OQFT@eTp }"_nB`]/Z4GU{:t|xo!tq. 7.0 PROCEDURE FOR HANDLING OF INCIDENT / DEVIATION: Any person (Initiator) can identify incident/unplanned deviation and shall initiate an incident/unplanned deviation record. For government agencies and organizations at every levelfrom federal or national to regional and localBig Data can have a huge impact on public health. select the relevant departments which are impacted by deviation. Each of these metrics focuses on determining product and process quality and sustainability. Generally speaking, we should work hard not to abuse temporary changes. Too many temporary changes demonstrate process control, stability, and repeatability problems. on the nature of deviation the Initiator shall take the immediate action in on the impact analysis and evaluation of the planned deviation and applies a risk management philosophy that remains data driven, . Head/Designee-QAD Executive/Designee Upon satisfactory review, the root cause and proposed CAPA shall be submitted to the QA Head/designee along with a summary of the investigation. QA "Top Issues for Pharma to Watch in 2022 and 2023. Submit completed record to the QA Head/designee for review. A planned deviation must be preapproved by the requesting department head and a QA Manager prior to implementation. The act or process, of evaluating (e.g. of Planned Deviations (But not limited to): Unplanned Quality Assurance shall be informed within one (1) working day of discovery of the incident. The following should be considered when investigating deviations: A root cause should be established with consideration given to: The possible root cause should be reported based on the evaluation and conclusion. departments for their comments. carryout the Impact assessment of the deviation on quality of Major deviations, that if not resolved may pose a risk to product quality should be closed in 30 days. deviation in deviation form. The deviation owner shall concur with all details and submit the deviation/incident for a risk assessment and deviation/incident criticality classification to the QA Head/designee. Classification of the deviation/incident. Capturing value at scale: The $4 billion RWE imperative. have an adverse impact on the safety, quality or purity of product. Deviations can be explained as any aberrations that come across on account of prior to proceed for permanent change. Minor deviations which are unlikely to pose a risk to product quality should be closed in 60 days or an interim report must be provided. CAPA within the Pharmaceutical Quality System 1 Martin VanTrieste, R.Ph SVP Amgen ICH Q10 Conference October 4-6, 2011 - Arlington, Virginia November 14-16, 2011 - Brussels, Belgium Meet the challenge of changing stakeholder demands and increasing cost constraints with IQVIA's integrated technology services and analytics-driven offerings. All planned deviations should contain the following details: The QA Manager must assess product impact. or process is under alteration and it is necessary to have data for observation This includes information from the many sources of deviation data that a global, integrated quality system provides. The pre-requisite tasks identified shall be assigned before implementation of the temporary change/planned deviation. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. A risk assessment shall be conducted if required to evaluate the impact of the proposed change (refer to the SOP for. Based An initial investigation is required within 3 days, with closure in 30 days. Reporting requirements should be detailed in a SOP and include: Critical deviations that pose a risk to product and animals must be escalated to senior management within 1 day of identification. Product 3.0 REFERENCES TAKEN FOR SOP OF INCIDENT / DEVIATION: SOP for Handling of Corrective and Preventive Actions, Quality Head/Designee shall be responsible for-. "Visit our investor relations site for more information. If correction is required, the deviation owner shall forward the correction proposal to QA for review. Z@C2B3cJyL09"dAz)PB'0(AG8CG :!N The Initiator shall provide the following information, but not limited to, as applicable: Name of block to which event/incident belongs / area, Description of the event observed, other related comments, Results file/document shall be attached (if any), Product details- include other potentially impacted batch/batches event/incident, Product stage, equipment involved (name and ID), Procedures/documents involved (SOPs, process documentation or product/material specifications), Document affected electronic systems impacted (computer information Technology, hardware or software), Document related product/material test results. reference purpose. Top Issues for Pharma to Watch in 2022 and 2023. some unforeseen reasons. All available data will be analysed and a report generated that includes: The integrity of the system should be confirmed. It shall be reported to supervisor immediately and documented in the system on the day of discovery, but not later than end of next working day; a unique identification number shall be assigned to the record. Clear direction for when a result can be deemed invalid (e.g. Artificial intelligence is accelerating opportunities. the approval of deviation by Head QA, the initiating department shall execute lay down the procedure to ensure deviation is identified, reported, assessed, Followed by (/) and then serial no of correction record. The If the deviation has any impact on product quality, purity or strength QA should be notified immediately. 11: Other post-approval commitments - 2 5: . departments and classify the deviation as major, minor or critical based on the Ultimately, GMP is all about the patient and achievement of customer expectations through conformance to their requirements. 925 0 obj <>stream shall forward the deviation to Head QA along with supporting documents. deviation form. A rationale for inclusion or exclusion of lots shall be documented in the report. Description of event observed, other related comments: (Name) (Designation) (Sign & Date), (Name) (Designation) (Sign & Date), (Name) (Designation) (Sign & Date). %%EOF Reason for the temporary change / planned deviation. QA Head/Designee shall review the incident/unplanned deviation and may seek additional information and/or suggest changes. It also covers novel types of medicines derived from biotechnological processes and the use of pharmacogenetics/genomics techniques to produce better targeted medicines. e.g. might affect subject/patient's safety and clinical data integrity at an investigator/physician site such as protocol deviation/violations . hD0 !U Usually, these are associated with onetime events or Temporary Changes and the change control system must be used for permanent changes. Information that can be used to identify and diagnose quality problems, and predict and prevent quality events as well. Arriello already provides deviation and CAPA management internally within our services to PV clients, which has been audited many times and has a world-renowned reputation for compliance. In RECOMMENDED PV SOPS. Additional documents included each month. After implementation of the correction, the deviation owner shall submit the correction implementation record to QA for review. endstream endobj 920 0 obj <>/Metadata 70 0 R/Outlines 207 0 R/PageLayout/OneColumn/Pages 913 0 R/StructTreeRoot 288 0 R/Type/Catalog>> endobj 921 0 obj <>/ExtGState<>/Font<>/XObject<>>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/Type/Page>> endobj 922 0 obj <>stream The number of acceptable retests when no root cause is identified. management and retention of pharmacovigilance records audit and deviation management Australian pharmacovigilance contact person and Qualified Person for Pharmacovigilance in Australia (QPPVA) which may or may not have the potential impact on product quality, system If A deviation is any departure from an approved instruction, procedure, specification, or standard. QA shall be notified when completion of a deviation/incident report exceeds assigned due dates. QA shall be informed of the incident / deviations on the day of discovery, but not later than end of next working day. Quality Head / designee shall compile Deviation/Incident trends on a monthly basis for discussion/review/evaluation and shall include following: Manufacturing Head and Quality Head or designee shall collectively analyse the deviation/incident trends and conclusions for further improvement at regularly scheduled management review meetings. other controls, based upon investigation conclusions of the deviations/incidents and associated corrections. Annexure 4: Flow Chart for Temporary Change/Planned Deviation Reporting and Investigation. Unleash your potential with us. A SOP must exist that outlines the process of CAPA management and tracking. Photocopy IQVIA Vigilance Platform is our secure SaaS environment built to simplify safety and PV processes, while boosting speed, accuracy, and efficiency. There shall be regularly scheduled management review of incidents/deviations reports to identify trends or quality issues. Sam Tomlinson appointed as VP of Global Drug Safety.Sam has over 20 years strategic and operational experience and will develop and direct our clinical and non-clinical pharmacovigilance services and solutions. department. Temporary Changes must be approved before execution and should be handled through approved change controlprocedures. What does this mean for the Pharma industry? No deviation is permitted from Pharmacopoeia and other Regulatory specifications. Janki Singh is experienced in Pharmaceuticals, author and founder of Pharma Beginners, an ultimate pharmaceutical blogging platform. h79"1 #h"BU/eKx'3MTF\MFTf4apK2S1xvD% ~x p C)w!6'En?:#oQw6{|`p'l=A&~AT#Rc~8Dd>'>V?FZ#% Contact ustoday to learn more. e&vib]Y 1x) f}0G9,Nk@Rr0M29{s This review provides a state-of-the-art introduction to the great variety of sources of safety information, both . personnel training) as a prerequisite for the change implementation are completed. Head/Designee-QAD Temporary Change/Planned Deviation Description: A complete and concise description of the planned event shall contain the following, but shall not be limited to: A statement of the temporary change / planned event (i.e. Harness the power of automation to execute streamlined end-to-end safety solutions while reducing costs. deviation. Type of temporary change / planned deviation. QA shall evaluate the proposal for implementing the change as a permanent change and provide approval, make a request for further data or may reject it if not found suitable. Assuring timely implementation of corrective actions and. After If the incident/unplanned deviation cannot be closed in this period, the deviation owner must submit a request for extension as per attachment of timeline supported with adequate justification and rationale to QA for approval before the closure is due. Deviations (a.k.a Unplanned Deviations) are also known as incidents, unplanned events, or uncontrolled events. To "Harness technology for a healthier world. IQVIA RIM Smart. Checkout, Consideration of notification to other affiliates or third parties, Defined batch numbers or anticipated timeframe, Current procedure and any other associated documents. Note: 1. The IQVIA Human Data Science Cloud is our unique capability designed to enable healthcare-grade analytics, tools, and data management solutions to deliver fit-for-purpose global data at scale. Our summer/fall co-op program is from July 17-December 15, 2023. A cross-functional team (SME) that includes section heads from quality, manufacturing, regulatory, QA/ and any other department deemed necessary, shall review the temporary change/planned deviation, evaluate the risk associated with and will reject or approve the temporary change for further processing. shall carry out trend analysis on quarterly basis as per Trend Analysis Head "Browse our library of insights and thought leadership. actions to be taken. of Originating department shall provide the justification, required extension Pharmacovigilance 1200+ Team of Professionals Global Scale and Reach Service Excellence Life Science Consulting Drugs, Biologics, and Medical Devices FDA and EMA Expertise Full Lifecycle Support Regulatory Aairs The ProPharma Group Advantage Improving Patient Health and Safety. requirements, specification and standard operating procedure resulting in BD/ 9PDJ`L The deviation owner can provide additional comments and attach additional files/documents, if required. QA shall track implementation of corrective actions and assess their effectiveness. %%EOF An interim report may be issued at 30 days if closure is not possible. QA shall disposition impacted products/batches and/or releases other controls, based upon investigation conclusions and associated corrections. - Update of the explanatory note for Risk management plan in accordance with Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 520/2012 Art 30(1); The deviation owner shall request additional information/details concerning the deviation/incident from the Initiator and CFT as necessary. justification/Period for which planned deviation is requested) of planned The Initiator may request additional work from the Responsible Person if attached justification was incomplete or not satisfactory. The notification frequency of quality deviations regarding the type of drugs available in the Brazilian market were 18 notifications (43.9%) involved in generic drugs, 11 (26.8%) involved in similar drugs, 7 (17.1%) involved in compounded drugs and 5 (12.2%) involved in brand-name drugs. Assessment, CAPA shall be recommended by Executive/Designee-QAD for minor, Short description, Task category (pre- requisite and non-pre-requisite), Task start date, Task due date, Responsible Person to complete the task. Ensure that all the CAPAs are submitted and are adequate before closure of the incident/unplanned deviation. In this age of big data, structuring your global quality system data is imperative, and properly structured data sets are a must. certain approved procedure for specific period of time or number of batches. Historically, the Pharmaceutical industry has called a deviation by two other names: either unplanned deviations or planned deviations. However, the regulators are asking industry to move away from that nomenclature as a best practice. If additional information is needed, submit the summary of details needed to the Initiator. product. Initiating department in consultation with Executive/Designee-QAD shall For compliance to GMP and the sake of continuous improvement, these deviations are recorded in real time, investigated with root cause analysis and corrective and preventative actions are implemented. All written and updated by GMP experts. Any departure from established standards that has caused or has high probability of causing adverse impact on product safety, quality, identity, potency or purity. until the investigation is complete or QA agree to the disposal. ']MI lKqTW*}ta@e7^d9&vk! hbbd``b`A: $H0Ow/bX 6iSIA@Y b``$/;@ #1 ________________________________END_______________________________________, Pingback: Deviation Process Flow? Email: Quality Agreement Technical (Contract Manufacturing), Depyrogenating Tunnel Qualification Protocol (PQ), Reference Standard, Working Standard Handling, Grounding Requirement for Equipment and Building, Microbial Limit Test (MLT) of Non Sterile Product, Microbiological Analysis of Material & Drug Product. The procedure must consider: All environmental test results for the room, Sterility testing of product if it was filled in the area at the time of excursion, Operators gowning qualification status and trend. QA Head/designee shall evaluate the recommended CAPA and may approve implementation of the CAPA or discontinue CAPA with documented justification (refer to the current version of the respective SOP. Managing deviations and other unexpected quality events is required by GMP, but properly capturing and measuring these events builds the foundation for the quality improvements regulators will demand from your organization as they renew their focus on quality. hbbd``b`A, $$A,k3e "@:?iSA@/b``@ Z; period for closing of deviation is of 30 days on the basis of request for The titles of these Good x Practice guidelines usually begin with Good and end in Practice. QA Guideline on good pharmacovigilance practices (GVP) Annex I - Definitions (Rev 4) Date for coming into effect of first version . In Follow our blog today! If Temporary change or Planned deviation need to be fully documented and justified. QAD shall issue Deviation Form on the basis of request of originating Unplanned Overdue deviations/incidents shall be escalated to management and be included in the QRB meetings if deemed necessary. %%EOF The Cross Functional Team shall reject the proposed temporary change/planned deviation and close it if the QA evaluation determines that there is an adverse impact on product quality. Mrs. Janki Singh is professional pharmaceuticals blogger, Founder and Author of Pharma Beginners, She has rich experience in pharmaceutical field. A temporary or interim need to deviate from a current approved requirement or to supplement, clarify or correct existing approved requirements. 59 pharmacovigilance systems for marketing authorisation holders, competent authorities of Member 60 States and the Agency. In March 2006, the EMA (at that time still called EMEA) published the "Reflection Paper on a proposed solution for dealing with minor deviations from the detail described in the Marketing Authorisation ". The investigation shall follow the procedures as described in the current version of the respective SOP. Extension of Deviation. regulatory requirements for feasibility of the deviation. cGxP is a general term that stands for current Good x Practice (x = Clinical, Engineering, Laboratory, Manufacturing, Documentation, Pharmaceutical, etc.). CAPA shall be implemented by originating department and the effectiveness of %PDF-1.5 % A deviation is a departure from standard procedures or specifications resulting in non-conforming material &/or processes, or where there have been unusual or unexplained events which have the potential to impact on product quality, system integrity or personal safety. QA shall issue the deviation form to initiator trough the document request form. The process includes various tests and evaluations conducted by regulatory agencies and independent testing organizations. These are the deviations which are discovered after it Connected, integrated, compliant. Once approved by QA, the deviation owner shall implement the proposed correction. Discover new insights, drive smarter decisions, and unleash new opportunities with the power of IQVIA Connected Intelligence.. and %PDF-1.5 % QA shall take necessary actions to notify customer(s) about the temporary change / planned deviation, wherever applicable. supporting documents, comments from other corporate functions and compliance to Reference number of deviation shall be mentioned in the This can be accomplished by eliminating the task. Head/Designee-QAD Taking necessary action to notify customers and Regulatory. were used. Your world is unique and quite different from pharma. A system must exist that logs and tracks planned deviations. It means we need to think differently about quality and the systems we deploy to manage it, because quality data is becoming critical to compliance. The planned deviation can be closed once approved and any corrective actions are completed. Faster decision making and reduced risk so you can deliver life-changing therapies faster. IQVIA Vigilance Platform is our secure SaaS environment built to simplify safety and PV processes, while boosting speed, accuracy, and efficiency. Annexure 1: Unplanned Deviation /Incident Form. For this browsing session please remember my choice and don't ask again. Connected, integrated, compliant. A detailed plan including responsibilities. QA shall review the proposal and may approve, if satisfactory or may seek additional information. Inadequacies identified during review shall be addressed with CAPA initiatives. CR/ADV/YY/NNN/01. The criteria, a system or process must attain to satisfy a test or other requirements. It means deviation from any written procedure that we have implemented. provided in deviation form. The ICH Steering Committee had taken a key decision that technical specifications should no longer be developed solely within ICH, but should be created in collaboration with Standards Development Organisations (SDOs) to enable wider inter-operability across the regulatory and healthcare communities. These steps can be accomplished through an electronic document management system or a manual, paper-based system, provided that the system allows incidents/deviations to be tracked and trended and allows appropriate follow up on any corrective and preventive actions and effectiveness checks. impact / risk assessment and shall give reason for same in Deviation Form. Any The deviation owner may identify the cross functional team (CFT) comprised of individuals from affected or other s, resources external or Subject Matter Expert(s) in area(s) relevant to the deviation/incident. deviation shall be initiated within 24 hours / next working day from the time 919 0 obj <> endobj A deviation is a departure from standard procedures or specifications resulting in non-conforming material &/or processes, or where there have been unusual or unexplained events which have the potential to impact on product quality, system integrity or personal safety. 0 Unleash your potential with us. Helping you create a healthier world for all by harnessing innovation to improve access to and delivery of healthcare with sustainable models. All changes should be evaluated for product impact, significance, and the need for requalification or revalidation. It has also been updated to comply with the . Annexure 5: Format for Target Date Extension of Deviation. This certificate GMP training course for management of deviations and non-conformances is ideally suited for: Anyone working in the pharmaceutical or medical device industry. Control. following the change control procedure as per current version of SOP of Change If the executed temporary change or planned deviation is found suitable for implementation on a permanent basis, then this shall be recommended for Change Control in the Temporary Change/Planned Deviation record. . This shall be submitted to Quality Head/designee for final approval. and QA. Quality Improvement Deviation may be raised if a potential weakness has been identified, and the implementation will require project approval. `wsv'a=8_Ibu|]iKdN.M6yY )}~5_xcpMhSdh}3[xfK0fqZ I>SqqixO!z8 Reviewing requests for extension of timelines for deviation/incident, Deriving appropriate CAPA and ensure adequate implementation of, The Disposition of impacted products/batches and/or releases. department Head/Designee along with QA shall be responsible for closing of hb```N6i~1C=|plZ>U8|;S{4L\:`i+*,=D Fhb`b4)E:&-Wv CKJkM$@Vo+8@0%:4|h`h`R``h0Jv0v?`00AA$ First unplanned deviation of 2020 shall be PB/UDV/20/001, second planned deviation of 2020 shall be PB/PDV/20/002. the product quality, classification, CAPA, supporting documents, comments from 210 SOPs, 197 GMP Manuals, 64 Templates, 30 Training modules, 167 Forms. SJ Pharma Consulting, LLC in Mendham, NJ has created a full set of standard operating procedures for drug safety, pharmacovigilance, and quality. Following is a list of areas where deviations can be observed: The purpose of this article is to establish the expected compliance standard and approach to investigating and resolving both planned and unplanned deviations at a GMP sites. deviated parameter) of unplanned deviation in deviation form. non-conforming material and/or processes or unusual and unexplained events The QA Manager may ask advice from other department heads such as Engineering or Development prior to approval. IQVIA enables genomic research via global access to a network of genomic-clinical data, proprietary technologies that enable federated analytics, and therapeutic area & bioinformatics expertise to help you answer your most pressing research questions. The work carried out by ICH under the Efficacy heading is concerned with the design, conduct, safety and reporting of clinical trials. All investigations must be clearly documented and attached to the Deviation Report. Timely resolution of all deviations/incidents. 6.0 DEFINITION OF TERMS USED IN SOP FOR INCIDENT / DEVIATION: The product specifications and acceptance/rejection criteria, such as acceptable quality level and unacceptable quality level, with an associated sampling plan, that are necessary for making a decision to accept or reject a lot or batch (or any other convenient subgroups of manufactured units). Controls and / or system suitability criteria. Intelligence, automation and integration. Discover new insights, drive smarter decisions, and unleash new opportunities with the power of IQVIA Connected Intelligence.. A CR is stand for Correction records followed by slash (/), followed by respective deviation no. From To, Format for Trending of Incident-Deviation, Conductivity Meter SOP for Operation,Calibration, Out of Specification Result in Microbiology - Guideline - Pharma Beginners, Analytical Method Transfer (USP 1224) Guideline - Pharma Beginners. XB=$NO[R`DA`mbny$yQng\Hk#?[:|,RJ)5r"B;P[f:uG'GxO#> 3si`-5~O+?Bn~apv]wyW{I"$C?XlQZ{hhKkM7}hEwsGrgQ&1\bW"!dHI"[ujc+HDUYoSZElxG)9ylZ?>;%etw>>["Jqe([ QA shall take necessary actions to notify customer(s) / Regulatory about the incident/unplanned deviation, wherever applicable. Deviation Deviations were not handled in accordance with the description in the deviation system Inadequate follow-up on the causes for adverse reaction report submitted too late Auditors do not have sufficient experience in pharmacovigilance and subsidiaries have not been audited 21 19 November, 2018 DKMA website: dkma.dk accessed November 2018 5.GS Associated documentation along with file attachment. The oversight and assessment of the deviation/incident. Planned deviation or Temporary Change that will be made permanent shall be processed according to the current version of the respective. major and critical deviations to prevent the recurrence of deviation. QA shall inform Quality Head, Regional Quality Head and Corporate Quality Compliance Head or respective designee of any deviation or incident that may potentially have a multi- impact or require market action SOP for. The system shall assure incidents/deviations are evaluated to determine whether they extend to other batches that might be implicated in the discrepancy or failure. Bringing together unparalleled healthcare data, advanced analytics, innovative technologies, and healthcare expertise to create intelligent connections that speed the development and commercialization of innovative medicines to improve patient lives. 0 Now deviation can be of two different types: A) Planned Deviation B) Unplanned Deviation Planned deviations are those deviations from the procedure that are planned and we know before they occur. on the impact, risk analysis and evaluation of the unplanned deviation QA shall "Capturing value at scale: The $4 billion RWE imperative. deviation which occurred during execution of an activity, which may or may not A summary of any concerns associated with the incident/unplanned deviation not resolved and how these concerns influence the disposition of the lot, product or process shall be provided. Effectiveness of previous corrective actions and notification requirements. A SOP must exist that describes the methodology for performing an OOS Investigation, the SOP must include instructions in relation to: Laboratory Investigation Protocols should always contain: The principal behind any re-testing, re-sampling, re-injections etc. deviation shall be closed within 30 working days after approval of the # finalizing the required set of CAPAs required to manage any potential or expected deviation . 100 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<18E5C537DE7E8F6BD9AE34F6C91AB478>]/Index[85 36]/Info 84 0 R/Length 88/Prev 764014/Root 86 0 R/Size 121/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream Not disposing of any items, including sample plates and isolates. For example, eliminate mixing errors by purchasing pre-mixed materials. Provide the justification / rationale for the specified temporary change / planned. material/product/system/documentation or any other. Vx@4X;`Y3;_=#gB(i/*zc1{ e%k"z{FxpuR~eT/Q}dl5z6j1V|W/__(m2Xx=. Drug Safety and Pharmacovigilance Harness the power of . of Unplanned Deviations (But not Limited to): Deviation shall carry out trend analysis of all deviation to assess. The deviation owner shall perform the changes and/or submit the additional information as requested to the QA Head/designee. Our hybrid and fully virtual solutions have been used more than any others. Example Annexure 7: Rolling Trends as Per Cause of Deviation. deviation that affects the quality of product or has substantial potential to The underlying (fundamental) reason for a detected quality issue/failure (non-conformity, defect or other undesirable situation), which, if eliminated or corrected, will prevent recurrence of the problem for the same reason. Harness technology for a healthier world. Together, we can help lead the future of healthcare with the extensive IQVIA network of assets, resources, clients, and partners.

How Much Are Norman Rockwell Plates Worth, Casa Grande Most Wanted, Articles D